Car Brands

The Most Reliable Used Car Brands

By Mike Richards Updated: 04/07/2020 Posted: 11/03/2017

So, you’re in the market for a used car, but you want to ensure that it’s most reliable used car brands and will stick with you for a number of years down the line. Looking at J.D. Power’s rating can be a key component to researching which cars offer the best reliability. From there, looking at the average of brands ensures a particular model isn’t a fluke with excellent ratings, but that the brand continuously offers vehicles that are more reliable than the average car. We’ll go over the best brands to consider when reliability is a high priority.


Honda CRV 2012Honda vehicles have an average reliability score of about 3.5 out of 5 and are known for being quality, reliable vehicles. As an example, the latest Ridgeline scores 4.5 out of 5, while the CRV, Accord Hybrid, and Accord all score at four out of five. However, the Odyssey does have a below-average score of 2.5 which pulls the average down a bit.

3 Most Popular Used Honda Cars

ModelYear RangeAvg. Retail Value
Honda Civic2014-2015 $                     12,400
Honda Accord2013-2014 $                     11,300
Honda CR-V2012-2013 $                     14,300

Source: Auto Trader & Kelly Blue Book



The BMW edges out the Honda, but only by a minute degree. The average reliability rating is a 3.5 out of five. Also unlike the Honda, the BMW has no low scores, only average and high ones. The X1 and X4 rated a three, while the 3 Series, 4 Series, X5, and X6 all rated a four, which is better than average. It may not be a five out of five, but it shows reliability over the entire line.

3 Most Popular Used BMW Models

ModelYearAvg. Retail Value
BMW X32007 $                       5,211
BMW 3 Series2011 $                     12,726
BMW 1 Series2013 $                     19,609

Source: Best Cars U.S. News


Used GMC SUVThe GMC holds an average reliability score of about 3.7 out of five and does not have a single model that rates below a three out of five on reliability. The models that ranked three include the Canyon and Yukon. On the other hand, the Sierra 1500 ranks a four and the Terrain hits a 4.5, which is the most reliable compact SUV score seen.


With the Lincoln, reliability is consistent over the years. Half of the lineup for the year pulls in a four, while the other half gets a 3.5. The two most popular models, the Navigator and Continental, each earned a ranking of four. Also, the average score came out to 3.7, but fairly close to 3.8.


Toyota has had excellent reliability ratings for years and boasts a 3.8 out of five. Both the Camry and Camry Hybrid scored five out of five, while the Avalon, Avalon Hybrid, and Corolla each pulled in an impressive 4.5 The lowest score goes to the Sienna at three, but it’s still a reliable minivan option.


At just below a score of 4 out of 5, the Buick lineup pulls in a 3.9. It also has one of the few 5 out of 5 ratings with the Buick LaCrosse. The Enclave and Regal hit a 3.5 out of five, and everything else offered got a four out of five rating.


Mercedes and Mercedes-Benz pulls in a 4.0 out of five on reliability rating and is more consistent than any other brand. The 2017 lineup has nearly entirely ratings of four out of five, but the standout is the midsize E-Class sedan which pulled in a 4.5 on reliability potential.


The Porsche is an exciting addition to the list as none of their vehicles earned below a four when it comes to predicted reliability. Every single car and SUV from Porsche receives a four or 4.5 out of five. The average reliability is 4.2, and the most reliable cars on the list include the Macan, 911, and Panamera.


Lexus CarsLexus is the most reliable car brand according to J.D. Power with three of their vehicles earning a perfect score. These include the LS, GS Hybrid, and Lexus GS. However, it’s worth knowing that the Japanese brand does have one three-star out of five vehicle, the Lexus IS, which is simply scored as average. However, their average reliability overall still stands at 4.3 out of 5.

These nine car brands offer some of the most reliable cars on the market today. Many also offer older versions with that same reliability factor. For those who want to ensure a car that will weather years on the road, this is a good list to start your research with. Don’t choose most unreliable car brands!